HostDining Property Valuations logo
Homeowner looking at property valuation notice and preparing objection documents to contest excessive tax assessment.

Appealing Your Property Tax Valuation: A Step-by-Step Guide

Receiving a property tax valuation notice with an assessment that seems excessively high or inaccurate can be frustrating. However, you have the right to contest your property valuation if you believe it is unfair or incorrect. With the right process and evidence, you can potentially have your property value reduced and save on overpaid taxes.

When To Appeal Your Valuation

You may want to dispute your property tax valuation if:

  • The assessed value seems significantly higher than the true market value or recent sales of comparable properties in the area.
  • There are factual errors in the property details like land area, number of bedrooms etc.
  • Major negatives impacting the value have been overlooked, like traffic noise, lack of access, dilapidated structures etc.
  • Only external inspection was done without considering internal condition and improvements.
  • Your area has been incorrectly zoned leading to unfair grouping with more expensive suburbs.

Gather Valid Evidence Against the Valuation

The valuation authorities make their assessment based on mass appraisal principles. To contest the property tax value successfully, you need solid evidence to prove why their valuation is inaccurate.

  • Compile sales data for at least 3 similar nearby properties clearly showing lower sold prices. Advertised listings alone may not suffice.
  • Get a private valuation report done by a certified professional valuer highlighting the flaws in the statutory valuation and determining a more appropriate market value through detailed analysis.
  • Present photos showing any deterioration, structural defects, easement infringements etc. overlooked in the valuation.
  • Reference recent tribunal decisions where similar properties were valued lower.

Review the Objection Process

Each state has specific processes and objection timeframes applicable. Reviewing the official valuation review guidelines will help build a strong case.

  • For council rates valuations, contact your local council to understand the objection process. There may be online objection forms available.
  • For land tax, the objection will be handled by the State Revenue Office or Valuer-General. Check their website for procedures.
  • Note important dates for submission of your written objection along with supporting evidence. Do not miss the deadline.
  • You may need to pay a fee for formal review of a disputed valuation in some states.

Present Your Objection Effectively

Follow these tips for presenting your valuation dispute in the best manner possible:

  • Highlight factual errors in the property details prominently.
  • Reference comparable lower-valued sales and attach the data.
  • Summarise the key reasons why your valuation is excessive compared to evidence.
  • Keep the tone professional and refrain from making accusations.
  • Include only relevant evidence. Too much data can dilute your case.
  • Reply promptly if the assessing authority asks for any additional details or clarification.

Be Prepared at Objection Hearings

If required, you may need to present your appeal against the property valuation at a formal hearing:

  • Rehearse your presentation beforehand for clarity and confidence.
  • Focus on the evidence and facts rather than emotions.
  • Stick to the allotted time and key elements of your case.
  • Answer questions politely even if they seem confrontational.
  • Accept the outcome gracefully rather than arguing, even if it goes against you.
  • Be open to a compromise valuation proposed by the authority.

By following the proper procedures and preparing diligently, you can hope to arrive at a fairer property assessment and reduce overpayment of property taxes.